Conflict of Interest Policy
Eureka: Journal of Educational Research requires every author, reviewer and editor to disclose any interest that could, or could reasonably appear to, affect the objectivity of peer review, editorial decisions or publication.
This policy protects the fairness, transparency and credibility of the double-blind peer review process at Eureka: Journal of Educational Research.
It applies to everyone involved in a submission:
- Authors, including all co-authors
- Reviewers, whether invited by the editors or recommended by the authors
- Editors, including the Editor-in-Chief, handling editors, guest editors and members of the editorial board
- Editorial office and publisher staff who handle manuscripts
Disclosure is required at submission and again whenever a new interest arises during review or production.
What Is a Conflict of Interest?
A conflict of interest (competing interest) is anything that interferes with, or could reasonably be perceived as interfering with, the full and objective presentation, peer review, editorial decision-making or publication of a manuscript.
- It can be financial or non-financial, professional or personal.
- It can arise in relation to a person, an institution, an organisation or a funder.
- Having a conflict does not by itself disqualify a manuscript or a person. Failing to disclose it does. When in doubt, disclose.
What Must Be Declared
Declare every interest that existed within 5 years before the research was conducted or the manuscript was prepared. Older interests must also be declared if they could reasonably be seen as competing.
| Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Financial | Paid employment or consultancy; ownership of shares; board membership; patents (pending or granted); research or travel grants; honoraria; gifts; funding from a company that makes or sells the product, tool or programme studied |
| Institutional | Employment by, or a leadership role in, the school, university, foundation or company whose programme, platform or curriculum is evaluated in the study |
| Professional | Current or recent collaboration, co-authorship or shared grants with an author; being a supervisor, mentor, student or direct subordinate of an author; membership of the same research group or committee |
| Personal | Family relationship, close friendship or personal rivalry with an author, reviewer or editor |
| Ideological | Strong political, religious or other convictions about the manuscript's topic that could bias an objective assessment |
| Journal-related | Membership of the Eureka editorial team or reviewer pool; involvement of Id-SRE or S&CO Publishing in the study |
In educational research, also disclose any commercial interest in educational technology, e-learning platforms or AI-assisted learning tools evaluated in the work, and any role in developing them.
Responsibilities of Authors
The corresponding author is responsible for collecting disclosures from all co-authors and submitting one complete statement with the manuscript.
Authors must:
- Disclose all financial and non-financial interests relevant to the work (see the table above).
- Name every funder and describe the funder's role in study design, data collection and analysis, writing, and the decision to publish.
- Declare any commercial affiliation of any author, and any commercial interest in a product, tool or platform evaluated in the study.
- Disclose any current role in the Eureka editorial team, and any personal or professional tie to the editors.
- Not recommend reviewers with whom they have a conflict, and disclose any known conflict if they suggest reviewers.
- Update the statement if circumstances change before publication.
The statement appears in the manuscript under Conflict of Interest (or Declaration of Competing Interest), before the references. Suggested wording:
- No conflict: The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
- Commercial affiliation: [Author name] is employed by [Company]. The remaining authors declare that the research was conducted without any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
- Funded, funder not involved: This study was funded by [Funder]. The funder had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, interpretation, writing of the article, or the decision to submit it for publication.
- Funded, funder involved: This study was funded by [Funder]. The funder was involved in [describe involvement].
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Because Eureka uses double-blind review, reviewer and author identities are not shown to each other and reviewer names are not published with the article. Reviewers therefore declare conflicts confidentially to the editor, before accepting the invitation or at any later point.
Decline the invitation, or withdraw, if any of the following applies:
- Family or close personal ties: an author is a spouse, relative or close friend, or you suspect a personal rivalry.
- Recent collaboration: you have worked, published or held a grant with an author, or have a manuscript in review with an author, within the past 2 years.
- Supervision: you supervised, mentored, or were supervised by or a student of an author within the past 3 years.
- Shared affiliation: you work, or recently worked, at the same institution or company as an author, or belong to the same committee, consortium or research group.
- Financial or commercial ties: you have a business relationship with an author, or a financial interest in the topic, the product studied or the funder.
- Strong convictions about the subject that you believe would prevent a fair evaluation.
Reviewers who identify an author from the content of the manuscript, and believe this creates a conflict, must tell the editor rather than contact the author. Reviewers must not use unpublished information from a manuscript for their own benefit or share it with others, and must not ask editors for the manuscript to be treated differently because of a relationship.
Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Board
Editors must declare their own conflicts, withdraw from any manuscript where one exists, and ask another editor to take over. The same reasons that apply to reviewers (family, collaboration, supervision, affiliation, finance) apply to editors.
Manuscripts submitted by editors. Editors, reviewers and board members may submit to the journal, but:
- They take no part in the handling, reviewer selection or decision on their own manuscript.
- The Editor-in-Chief, or another editor with no conflict, handles it.
- Their editorial role is stated in the conflict of interest statement.
- The manuscript follows the same double-blind review as every other submission.
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief. The Editor-in-Chief takes no part in the process, and an independent editor, not affiliated with the author's institution, makes the decision.
Staff of Id-SRE and S&CO Publishing. Employees or officers of the publisher or the collaborating society who submit a manuscript must tell the editorial office at submission, are excluded from handling it, and state the affiliation in the manuscript.
Guest editors and special issues. Guest editors do not handle manuscripts they authored, or by authors with whom they have a conflict, and the Editor-in-Chief reviews the decision on any such paper.
Editors also decline to invite reviewers who have a conflict with the authors, and may not treat a disclosed conflict as a reason to give a manuscript an easier or harder review.
How Disclosed Conflicts Are Handled
- Screening. The editorial office checks every submission for a conflict of interest statement. A manuscript without one is returned to the authors before review.
- Assessment. The handling editor decides whether a disclosed interest could bias review or the decision. Most disclosed interests, such as a grant from a non-commercial funder, do not prevent review.
- Action. Depending on the case, the editor may reassign the manuscript, choose different reviewers, ask a reviewer to withdraw, or ask the authors for more information.
- Transparency. Relevant declarations are published with the article. Reviewer disclosures remain confidential to the editorial team.
- Record. The editorial office keeps a record of declarations and the action taken for each manuscript.
Disclosure is never held against an author. Editors judge the manuscript on its scientific merit and ethical conduct.
Undisclosed or Misreported Conflicts
The journal follows the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). Depending on when the conflict is found:
| Stage | Possible action |
|---|---|
| Before or during review | Request for a full disclosure; rejection of the manuscript if the conflict is serious or was deliberately withheld; replacement of reviewers or editors |
| After acceptance, before publication | Re-review by an independent reviewer; correction of the statement; withdrawal of acceptance |
| After publication | Publication of a correction, or an expression of concern; retraction if the conflict undermines the validity of the work, as described in the journal's Retraction policy |
Where misconduct is established, the journal may also inform the institutions or funders concerned and may decline future submissions. Concerns about a published article can be reported to the editorial office, and will be investigated confidentially.
How to Declare and Whom to Contact
- Authors: complete the conflict of interest statement in the manuscript and confirm it in the submission system. Use the Eureka template.
- Reviewers and editors: report conflicts to the Editor-in-Chief or the editorial office as soon as you notice them, preferably before accepting an assignment.
- Late discoveries or doubts: write to the editorial office at admin.eureka@id-sre.org or eurekaidsre@gmail.com, with the manuscript title and a short description of the interest.
This policy should be read with the journal's Publication Ethics, Peer-Review Process, Plagiarism, Retraction and Withdrawal of Manuscripts policies.